Julian Is Disgusted at His Mother's Racism and Elitism, While the Reader Can Observe That Julian:
§ 18. Emancipation: Gender and Race
Gender
The saying that anatomy is destiny pervaded Victorian anthropology every bit it did Victorian religious sects. Clerics understood that Eve was to Adam equally Adam was to God, and anthropologists understood that women, Australian aborigines, and African people had smaller and simpler, less convoluted, brains than did white men. Huxley agreed with this paradigm, though his applied application of it differed a little from that advocated by more consistent sexists and racists. He did non notice New Guinea women much different from English women, and enjoyed them (conversationally, non carnally)– Baronial 26, 1849 . "The girls were very merry and unconstrained though perfectly modest in their behaviour. They seemed one-half inclined to accept a dance as well but had not the courage. It tickled me very much to encounter how perfectly women are women all the world over. There was the aforementioned incessant flow of small-scale talk among themselves, the same caressing and putting their arms round ane another, as would have been seen in any other grouping of women in any other place from London to Sydney. And to complete the resemblance they all persisted in kissing and hugging an impudent young varlet of a ship's male child who went down on the catamaran equally they were going abroad. One of these damsels, who had disfigured her face up by a copious coat of black pigment, was more affectionate than any of the others and seemed to accept a most roguish delight in inspecting the traces of her kindness, left very visible upon the boy's white face."What happened to a European adult female who was captured, saved, and treated cordially past these natives is recounted in October 16, 1849 and October 18, 1849 .
- Wookduoo
- Pencil sketch of Cape York woman
- "Waitcha"
- Cape York female parent and baby
- Community
- Customs of native women, 1849
For years after his return to England, Huxley commented in his essays and messages very footling on whatever gender subject. When a correspondent asked his opinion nigh the propriety of a certain biology textbook, Huxley replied: "Adolphe Grube grubs non much about the ballocks–& you demand take no fright of any phallic phantoms equally the annelida enantia & tubicula are improvided with whatever such improprieties" (HP 15.42). He explained his disinclination to teach at a woman's higher by asking what he would do "among all the virgins, young and onetime, in Bedford Square? ... depend upon it I should exist turned out in a week (though I don't drink) for some forgetful excursion into the theory of Parthenogenesis or worse" (to J. Furnivall, Dec 14, 1856, Huntington MS.). His comment that he had "an unutterable fear of scientific women"– April nine, 1855 –may also have been a joke Jokes on sex are as rare in Huxley as they are in John Newman.
Every bit Secretary of the Geological Society, Huxley opposed admitting women to that clan, because that clan was only for professionals, all of whom were men. Charles Lyell wondered if about the subject area of women, Huxley was like "the Bp of O" (the Bishop of Oxford), Huxley defending his position past telling Lyell that women should receive equal opportunities as men–advancing such opportunities would be only to them, amongst whom were the Huxley daughters, and to society: no permanent advancement could be made "while half of the race is sunk, as nine-tenths of women are, in mere ignorant parsonese superstition"– March 17, 1860 .
The most of import essay of his on this issue is Emancipation–Black and White (1865). In a passage that would be of interest to today's feminists, he dismisses fanatical "philogynists" (this discussion his invention) too every bit misogynists who define the female person nature equally virtuous, impressionable, emotive, patient, and some of whom observe the male figure more than cute than the female: "womanly beauty, so far as it is independent of grace or expression, is a question of pall and accessories."
Even if such arguments, "comparable to those by which the inferiority of the negro to the white man may be demonstrated," may have a foundation, they are of no value when it comes to considering emancipating women. Women should take the same ceremonious and political rights equally men. "[T]hose who may express mirth at the arguments of the extreme philogynists, may yet feel bound to work heart and soul towards the attainment of their practical ends." If women do have the "declared defects," it is cool to maintain a organisation of instruction which exaggerated those defects. "Sweet girl graduates ... will be none the less sweet for a little wisdom; and the 'golden hair' volition not curl less gracefully outside the head by reason of at that place beingness brains inside." The duty of man is to see that non a grain is piled upon that load beyond what nature imposes; that injustice is not added to inequality.
Huxley was a supporter of, though not an ardent advocate of, women's rights. A journalist, Miss Eliza Lynn, so admired Huxley equally scientist, that she wanted to become a member of the Ethnological Lodge; just Huxley denied her admission to information technology. He was opposed to allowing women to become members of what he saw equally an association for experts in the field, not as a opportunity for adult instruction. He had never permitted women to be students in his ain Comparative Anatomy courses because they would accept to share gross anatomizing with men. Sophia Lousia Jex Blake, a designer of the London Medical School for Women, wrote to Huxley in 1872 requesting his help in having carve up anatomy classes for women medical students at Edinburgh; in his reply, Huxley said that he supported programs which would advance the prospects of women who wanted to become physicians. He would not hesitate to teach anything to a grade equanimous entirely of women: to Jex Blake– October 28, 1872 , and did teach such a course; in 1869, he taught a grade in physiography to a class of 3 hundred women, the observation of a reporter that it was similar "a fairy tale" being praise rather than insult ( Professor Huxley, F.R.S .)
In a letter two years later on to The Times, Huxley confessed publicly that many women are better endowed than many men in intellectual and moral strength, "and I am at a loss to empathise on what grounds of justice or public policy a career which is open up to the weakest and about foolish of the male sex should be forcibly closed to women of vigour and capacity"– Alphabetic character on Miss Jex Blake The Times (July 8, 1874). Topping several reasons for his dislike of Comte was the homo's maltreatment of the "noble" wife who had saved his life and his reason– Apr 12, 1869 .
Among the events he really performed to achieve equality in education for women were his vote on the London Schoolhouse Board confronting an subpoena excluding girls from the Scheme of Education; supporting women'southward institutions such as Girton Gollege, South Hampstead High School for Girls, Princess Helena College for Girls (at Ealing); employing a woman, Miss McConnish, every bit a physiology demonstrator; signing a petition (in 1880) to Cambridge to open its doors to women; a few years later signing a petition to allow Mrs. Besant, who had been a educatee in his teacher'southward course ("a very well-conducted lady-like person"), and Miss Bradlaugh (whose father, the atheist Charles Bradlaugh, was non one of Huxley's favorite philosophers) to take courses at University Higher; as Dean of the Normal School of Science at Southward Kensington, promoting opening Associateships of the School to women; and becoming a governor of the London School of Medicine for Women (founded in 1875)– July 18, 1883 .
In March 1889 , he wrote that he agreed with his daughter about French women. "They are like French dishes, uncommonly well cooked and sent up, just what the dickens they are made of is a mystery. Not merely what all womankind are mysteries, simply there are mysteries of godliness and mysteries of iniquity." Ane mystery of iniquity was provided by George Eliot, whom Huxley met at the Westminster Review, Eliot disapproving of Huxley'due south attacks on K. H. Lewes and Comtism. Huxley was a frequent invitee at Eliot soirees, which he would attend without the visitor of his wife. Every bit Julian Huxley noted in Memoirs, "He often called on the famous writer, George Eliot, whom he gratly admired, however never allowed his wife to accompany him, for George Eliot was 'living in sin' with a homo who was non her legal husband." Upon George Eliot'due south death, Huxley declined to support a petition to have her buried at Westminster Abbey because equally a secularist, she had no place there. Neither did he, though, reasonably plenty, Darwin did.
An anonymous letter of 1882: Anonymous Extract from Journal , describes conversation at a party, its chief topics Truth, Education, and Women's Rights. To the hostess' need that truth was no virtue in itself, Professor Huxley replied that he was "near a fanatic for the sanctity of truth"; on the question of women's rights, the professor confessed that looking at women with the eye of the physiologist, twenty years earlier he had thought "the womanhood of England was going to the dogs," simply things had improved, Victorian ladies at present having not only tennis, but also more than pursuits. "The almost accomplished of the Queen's daughters said of him," reports the journalist Westward. Smalley (in London Messages, 1890), "'I like to talk with Mr. Huxley because he talks to me exactly every bit he would to any other woman.'" On the other manus, to John Skelton he wrote on December 31, 1881 , that Mary Stuart was like Eve, Helen, Cleopatra, Delilah in having "lured men to their devastation."
He asked his friend John Donnelly to requite Lady Donnelly this note: "A number of estimable members of her sex have flown at me for writing what I thought was a highly complimentary letter. But she volition be but, I know. The all-time of women are apt to exist a picayune weak in the great practical arts of give-and-have, and putting upwards with a beating, and a piffling besides strong in their belief in the efficacy of government. Men learn about these things in the ordinary course of their business; women have no chance in home life, and the boards and councils will be capital schools for them. Again, in the public interest it will exist well; women are more naturally economical than men, and have none of our fake shame about looking afterwards pence. Moreover, they don't job for whatever only their lovers, husbands, and children, and then that we know the worst"– Nov eleven, 1894 .
Huxley was not uxorious, but his love for, his respect and admiration of his fiance and then married woman Henrietta Heathorn, lasted undiminished for half a century. From his office at Jermyn Street, he would often write her two messages daily–testify of this attachment will exist establish in Jeanne Pingree, Thomas Henry Huxley: List of His Correspondence with Miss Henrietta Heathorn, 1847-1854, Julian Huxley, Voyage of H. One thousand. Southward. Rattlesnake, and Leonard Huxley, Life and Messages.
- "Journal"
- Hal and Nettie on honeymoon gunkhole, 1855
- HHH-1857
- Henrietta Heathorn, 1857
- Lynton
- Photograph by Mrs. Bailey at Lynton, 1882
Marian Huxley Collier died in 1889. John Collier then courted her sister Ethel. Huxley welcomed this, but the English law system did not, and so Huxley devoted energy to disbanding the act forbidding marriage with a deceased married woman'south sister– Jan 21, 1889 (which also discusses Shakespeare on the sex activity of plants) and April 20, 1889 .
The Negro Question
Almost all nineteenth century anthropologists (an exception might exist Professor Tiedemann) agreed on a hierarchy of races, African blackness and Australian aborigine at the bottom and Europe white (male) at the top–run across for example Owen quoted in Guide 7. Huxley parodied the Wedgwood tribute to emancipation, "Am I not a Man and a Blood brother?" in a drawing, "Am I non a homo & a brother?" displaying himself in a prison ship hulk (Punch would subsequently also parody that in Monkeyana ); and in Rio de Janiero, which the Rattlesnake arrived at in January, Lieutenant Huxley found, as his mentor Carlyle had plant, that slaves were "mostly in majuscule condition, and on the whole expect happier than the corresponding class in England, the manufacturing and agricultural poor, I hateful."
Huxley's contribution to soapbox on races shows him to be less a racist than most of his clerical or scientific peers. Like Darwin, he despised the slave-masters of Madeira and Rio de Janeiro, feeling sympathy for the slaves–letter to his mother, March 28, 1847 ; and he had a greater respect for these slaves than for their masters– January 24, 1847 and March 28, 1847 . Depression assailing him during Rattlesnake sailing was often relieved by sketching and bartering with, dancing with, exchanging names with, and in full general having fun with, natives, see for case– May 4, 1847 , July 6, 1849 , and August 26, 1849 . He supported the theory that Louisians had cultivated their land (as opposed to the reverse idea that what seemed to exist cultivation was really only a natural effect– June 13, 1849 ; and defended native gentility against British brutality– September 5, 1849 .
- Upcountry
- Conviviality at upcountry Australia, sketch by Hal on ride to Darling Downs, December 5, 1847
- Hal being painted
- Rockingham Bay
- "Interview with natives of Redscar Bay"
- 1848
From 1854 to 1857, Huxley wrote a dozen papers on "Contemporary Literature: Science" for the Westminster Review. In an 1854 review of "On Types of Mankind," he declined to accept a stand up on whether blacks were of a species different from whites (a thesis argued by Agassiz), but emphatically scourged slavery as an atrocious institution, as degrading to those who skillful it equally it was cruel to those who suffered from it– Brewster, et al. He found no trouble in entertaining the view that blacks are as authentic members of the human species every bit white Europeans. Huxley subscribed to the general anthropological (and theological and cultural) stance of a hierarchy of races–see for example, The Structure and Classification of the Mammalia (1864) and the Reader's abstract, Mammalia.
The unanimity among racist anthropologists focused on concrete features that showed people of "lower races" to be closer to apes than were Europeans. For example, Professor Richard Owen in The Gorilla and the Negro used doctored illustrations to show that kinship, and James Chase, the President of the Anthropological Society focused on the Negro's pelvis and leg bones to show that kinship. Huxley dissected Owen's illustrations and Owen himself in letters to the Athenaeum: Man and the Apes (1861). By 1863, Huxley had made up his listen that the evidence demanded belief in all races comprising one species– On Our Knowledge of the Causes of the Phenomena of Organic Nature ; in 1864 Huxley attacked Hunt severely in The Construction and Nomenclature of the Mammalia and in The Negro's Place in Nature .
Though Huxley subscribed to the prevailing bureaucracy of lower and higher races, his belief in monogenesis and his disgust at slavery were sufficiently attractive to the Ladies Emancipation Order to inspire this abolishionist grouping to print this upward in a pamphlet, which Huxley kept in his papers for the balance of his life– Professor Huxley on the Negro Question (May 1864). In the early 1880s, he wrote a typhoon of "The Negroes," which never was sent off for publication.
"Emancipation: Black and White" spends far less time on the lower races than it does on the lower gender. In this essay, however, he says about the people of lower races what he says about the people of lower gender: that injustice ought not to exist added to inequalilty, that blacks ought to be given all opportunities. Huxley'due south sympathy in the U. Due south. Civil War was with Southern culture; but his antipathy to slavery insured his being a supporter of the Northerners. He explained this in a letter to his expatriate sis, Lizzie–"it is articulate to me that slavery ways, for the white man, bad political economy; bad social morality; bad internal political organisation, and a bad influence upon free labour and liberty all over the world. For the sake of the white human, therefore, for your children and grandchildren, directly, and for mine, indirectly, I wish to see this system ended. Would that the s had had the wisdom to initiate that end without this miserable war!"– May iv, 1864 .
At an 1867 Birmingham talk, Huxley advised his audition that there was no relation between cranial book and facial features (certain features of white people were more ape-like than the features of non-whites, e.m., hair texture), that people who lacked cultural and technological achievements today demand not lack them tomorrow, and that miscegenation did non consequence in the defects the American supporters of slavery insisted it did.
A coherence was discovered then (as it is today) amid, in the words of the Standard, "Atheists, Socialists, advocates of 'complimentary dear', or universal licentiousness, of women's rights, and every other anathema or absurdity which institute favour in infidel France, in philosophical Frg, and in democratic America, simply which religious and loyal Engishmen abhor and loathe."
An event occurred in 1865 which showed, every bit one of its lesser features, Huxley's entire abandoment of his early Carlylean affection for slavery. Contemporaneous with the Civil War was a mission undertaken by the Governor of Jamaica in response to a riot which he thought was the get-go of a rebellion by the land's blacks against its white administrators. In three days, Governor Eyre'due south army killed four hundred natives, amid them a mulatto member of Jamaica's parliament. When the word got dorsum to England, several of the elite formed The Jamaica Committee, its intention to bring the Governor to Britain and effort him for murder.
John Stuart Mill was chair of this committee, which had among its members Francis Newman, Charles Lyell, Charles Darwin, Herbert Spencer, and T. H. Huxley. The Drapery Mall Gazette (1866) was not surprised at this: "Information technology would be curious besides know how far Sir Charles Lyell'south and Mr. Huxley'due south peculiar views on the evolution of species have influenced them in bestowing on the negro that sympathetic recognition which they are willing to extend even to the ape as 'a human being and a brother'" Huxley's answer to this appeared on October 31, 1866, in the Pall Mall Gazette: Letter on Jamaica Committee and in private letters such equally those to his pen-pal Charles Kingsley– November eight, 1866 and to his closest friend, John Tyndall– November 9, 1866 . Kingsley and Tyndall, forth with Dickens, Thackeray, and Tennyson, supported the Eyre Defense force Committee, chaired by Thomas Carlyle.
1867 seems to be a year of transition from a conventional racist view about our "prognathous relatives" and "dusky cousins" to i more than expressive of racial equality. In lectures on "The Character, Distribution and Origin of the Principal Modifications of Mankind" to the Birmingham and Midland Institute (of which he was President, his predecessor Charles Dickens) in that year, he claimed that there was no scientific evidence that whatever grouping of people was innately dissimilar from, or more biologically advanced than, any other; he also declined to apply words such every bit "species," "varieties," and even "races" for human populations–Birmingham Post, October seven, 8, and 12, 1887. In an 1878 commentary on a paper discussing Celts and Teutons, Huxley pointed out that the characteristics of a "race" might be due to "pre-existing social and political relations"; he did not believe "that race has whatsoever appreciable influence upon their social and political conditions of the present day." He was referring to the Scotch, Irish, and English, and did not explicitly extend this generalization to African people– Practical Fallacies (1878).
See: § 3. A Sort of House and § 19. Aryans et al.: Ethnology .
| T HE H UXLEY F ILE |
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Source: http://aleph0.clarku.edu/huxley/guide18.html